Director:
Mel GibsonCámara:
Simon DugganMúsica:
Rupert Gregson-WilliamsReparto:
Andrew Garfield, Vince Vaughn, Sam Worthington, Luke Bracey, Teresa Palmer, Hugo Weaving, Rachel Griffiths, Milo Gibson, Richard Roxburgh (más)Streaming (5)
Sinopsis(1)
Japón, 1945. Desmond Doss (Andrew Garfield), un hombre contrario a la violencia, se alista en el ejército de EEUU para servir como médico de guerra en plena II Guerra Mundial. Tras luchar contra todo el estamento militar y enfrentarse a un juicio de guerra por su negativa a coger un rifle, consigue su objetivo y es enviado a servir como médico al frente japonés. A pesar de ser recibido con recelo por todo el batallón durante la salvaje toma de Okinawa, Desmond demuestra su valor salvando a 75 hombres heridos consiguiendo el respeto de los soldados. (DeAPlaneta)
(más)Videos (24)
Reseñas (18)
Konečně po delší době zase výborný film a rovnou válečný. Jsem poměrně dost alergický na americkou válečnou produkci posledních let, takže Hacksaw Ridge je pro mě příjemným osvěžením. Když budu sarkastický, tak to bude možná Gibsonem a Australany, že z toho zase nevznikla americká oslavná pitomost. Mel Gibson si u mě v jistém okamžiku získal velké sympatie, a proto mu pár amerických scén odpustím, protože jemu rozhodně věřím, že nebude jásat nad americkou dokonalostí a neomylností. Andrew Garfield měl hodně náročný rok, vedle Mlčení si střihnout ještě roli Desmonda Dosse, muselo mu to dát hodně zabrat, proto je oscarová nominace zasloužená. Když jsem se díval na béčkový horor Zhasni a zemřeš, netušil bych, že hlavní herečku uvidím zanedlouho v áčkovém snímku. No a co dodat k mému oblíbenému komediálnímu herci Vincu Vaughnovi? Já se musím smát, i když hraje vážné role.
()
Algunos momentos resultan simplistas y poco pensados, pero desde el punto de vista emocional, la película funciona. Y un trabajo limpio con el aspecto visual del Hollywood dorado siempre complace. Pero Braveheart se adentraba más en el conflicto de personajes, y la rebeldía del protagonista era más apasionada. Hasta el último hombre, por otro lado, sigue siendo «solo» un elegante drama de guerra bastante suave, endurecido por entrañas sangrientas y cien agujeros de bala. Garfield está bien, hasta ahora su mejor papel.
()
If the child version of Andrew Garfield had been hit in the mouth with a brick at the beginning of Hacksaw Ridge instead of his movie brother, the whole film would have made a lot more sense. I wasn’t really sure how seriously I should take a young man with the face of a divine simpleton who isn’t overly familiar with how interpersonal relationships work, let alone international politics. In any case, the film takes him seriously enough to gradually lose all credibility. Instead, it offers an enormous dose of stupidity. It seems to me that the final Assumption scene wandered into the film from an unaired Monty Python sketch. The concept that forms the basis of the entire film is reminiscent of the theatre of the absurd. To make the hero of the biggest explosion of disembowelled guts and blown-off heads since Saving Private Ryan a very devout pacifist who rejects violence of any kind strikes me as a rather cruel irony. It doesn’t seem, however, that Mel Gibson is aware of that. He doesn’t use the scenes of slaughter (which soon become numbing rather than shocking) to lead Desmond to the realisation that war is a lot more hellish than he imagined it would be (in which case the contrast of the first and second halves of the film would have worked better), but to show how hard the boy will have it if he wants to survive longer than a split second without a rifle in his hand. The creation of a hero who rejects violence is thus paradoxically conditioned by pervasive violence. If his buddies had not been torn to pieces by the bullets and grenades of the savage Japanese (an ethnic stereotype that went out of fashion along with John Wayne), he could not have become a hero. I don’t doubt that someone else will find clear logic in what I myself see as an irreconcilable contradiction, but even if it didn’t seem to me that the film is ridiculous at its very core, I would have a hard time finding reasons to recommend it to anyone as an example of the best of what has been made in Hollywood this year. We have seen powerful and generally uncluttered depictions of the pandemonium of war many times before, and the clear narrative structure and textbook segmentation, thanks to which such films never even start to be boring, are qualities that have characterised American films for many decades. Hacksaw Ridge, however, is somewhat underdeveloped both intellectually and formalistically. 60%
()
Laughing in atheist Czechia at the Catholic Gibson going over the top in the story of a soldier who refuses a gun for religious reasons seems like a cheap pose to me. The truth is that just as Gibson does not discount his position as a devout Christian, he does not discount filmmaking compromises. The first hour might have deserved to be turned up a notch and let the viewer peek inside the heads of those for whom a gun is a certainty in war, but the second half is a Rambo-esque rendering plant that, with its refined camera, editing, and sound-chiseled aesthetics, turns a wartime hell into an almost hypnotically artistic experience. This was last done by Ridley Scott at the start of the new millennium. You can have whatever feelings you want about it throughout, but when Garfield's limited acting works at the end, it turns into an emotional waterfall that for once I didn’t feel awkward about. 4 ½.
()
The rumors that Hacksaw Ridge is a cruel carnage have been confirmed. At least the scene when the protagonists enter the battlefield for the first time is really not for the faint of heart and will probably be talked about for a while. How the film will fare overall, though, I can't say, but I'm afraid a lot of viewers won't be able to stomach this. Mel Gibson is a great director and it shows here not only in the battle scenes, where he allows himself to do some really wild stuff from time to time, but audiovisually overall. The trouble, however, may be that Hacksaw Ridge looks like something from the last century, and not from the 1990s. The hero is more naive and passionate about a good cause than Forrest Gump, the characters are downright shallow at times, and everything here is either black (Dobbs, you're a naive idiot and you're going to get your ass kicked) or white (Dobbs, we'll follow you to hell). Gibson was probably trying to do just that, and if you accept the rules of the game, you get a very good hero story that you may question how much it has to do with reality, but you will enjoy it. But if you don't tune in to the director's wave, you can suffer through Hacksaw Ridge. So watch out!
()
Anuncio